The Need For Multiple Warehouse Architectures

James Serra argues in favor of a data lake approach and a traditional data warehouse:

I think the ultimate question is: Can all the benefits of a traditional relational data warehouse be implemented inside of a Hadoop data lake with interactive querying via Hive LLAP or Spark SQL, or should I use both a data lake and a relational data warehouse in my big data solution?  The short answer is you should use both.  The rest of this post will dig into the reasons why.

I touched on this ultimate question in a blog that is now over a few years old at Hadoop and Data Warehouses so this is a good time to provide an update.  I also touched on this topic in my blogs Use cases of various products for a big data cloud solutionData lake detailsWhy use a data lake?and What is a data lake? and my presentation Big data architectures and the data lake.  

Read on for James’s argument, which is good.  My argument is summed up as follows:  the purpose of a data warehouse is to solve known business problems—that is, to help build reports that people on the business side need based on established requirements.  The purpose of a data lake is to hold all kinds of data and curate it for when people come looking for something they didn’t know they needed.

Related Posts

Kafka Topic Reuse

Martin Kleppmann walks through the trade-offs of reusing Apache Kafka topics for different event types: The common wisdom (according to several conversations I’ve had, and according to a mailing list thread) seems to be: put all events of the same type in the same topic, and use different topics for different event types. That line of […]

Read More

Set Operations In Spark

Fisseha Berhane compares SparkSQL, DataFrames, and classic RDDs when performing certain set-based operations: In this fourth part, we will see set operators in Spark the RDD way, the DataFrame way and the SparkSQL way. Also, check out my other recent blog posts on Spark on Analyzing the Bible and the Quran using Spark and Spark […]

Read More

Categories

December 2017
MTWTFSS
« Nov Jan »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031