Dropping Unique Key Constraints

Kenneth Fisher doesn’t like the way SQL Server implements unique key constraints:

So now that we all know the basics what could possibly have gone wrong? Well I was handed an error.

Msg 3723, Level 16, State 5, Line 21
An explicit DROP INDEX is not allowed on index ‘TblUniqueConstraint.uni_TblUniqueConstraint’. It is being used for UNIQUE KEY constraint enforcement.

Someone had created a process several years ago that dropped and re-created indexes (I’m not going to go into why right now). Well this particular index is used to enforce a unique constraint and so it can’t be dropped. If you want to follow along here is some quick code to duplicate the problem.

The appropriate way to drop a unique key constraint is ALTER TABLE [TableName] DROP CONSTRAINT [ConstraintName].

I disagree with Kenneth that there’s no value in unique key constraints (I’m guessing implicit in here is “in comparison to using CREATE UNIQUE NONCLUSTERED INDEX” syntax).  There’s a semantic difference between an index which happens to be unique versus a unique key constraint.  They’re implemented very similarly, but the point of the latter is to tell anybody using the data model that this set of attributes must be unique.

Related Posts

Predicting Advertising Budgets With Kafka Streams

Boyang Chen explains how Pinterest uses Kafka Streams to reduce advertising overdelivery: Overdelivery occurs when free ads are shown for out-of-budget advertisers. This reduces opportunities for advertisers with available budget to have their products and services discovered by potential customers. Overdelivery is a difficult problem to solve for two reason: Real-time spend data: Information about […]

Read More

Using Kafka To Drive Machine Learning

Kai Waehner has a nice architectural post on using Kafka as the focal point for machine learning training and prediction: The essence of this architecture is that it uses Kafka as an intermediary between the various data sources from which feature data is collected, the model building environment where the model is fit, and the […]

Read More


December 2015
« Nov Jan »