Category: Columnstore

Niko Neugebauer looks at how columnstore indexes differ between SQL Server Standard Edition, Express Edition, and Enterprise Edition:

One rather small (relatively other features, as I imagine), but an incredibly useful improvement was described in Columnstore Indexes – part 109 (“Trivial Plans in SQL Server 2017”) – is the ability to automatically produce Fully Optimised execution plans for the Database, which compatibility level is set to 140.

Running on both instances (Standard & Express), the following script, while altering the compatibility level between 140 (SQL Server 2017) & 130 (SQL Server 2016), will produce different execution plan for the SELECT COUNT_BIG(*) operation – the fast one (with FULL optimisation in 140 compatibility level) and slow one (with TRIVIAL optimisation in 130 compatibility level):

I am happy that this feature has got no Edition dependence, this is a needed improvement that simply increases the value of the offer and can actually be achieved in a lot of different ways, event without parallelism kicking in.

Niko has also helpfully provided a table at the end of the post to summarize his findings.

Niko Neugebauer continues his columnstore index series, this time looking at how partitioned tables behave:

Let’s start with a simple test of merging the 2007 partition with the year 2008, by issuing the following command:

1 2	ALTER PARTITION FUNCTION pfOnlineSalesDate ()   MERGE RANGE (‘2008-01-01’);

It might ready you a reasonably huge surprise, but this command will fail, if you are using the Columnstore Indexes.

1 2 3

Msg 35344, Level 15, State 1, Line 26 MERGE clause of ALTER PARTITION statement failed because two nonempty partitions containing a columnstore index cannot be merged. Consider disabling the columnstore index before issuing the ALTER PARTITION statement, then rebuilding the columnstore index after ALTER PARTITION is complete.

The very same command will function without any problem, if we would simply avoid creating Clustered Columnstore Index …
The reason behind this limitation has to do with the fact that Columnstore Indexes do not sort or control the boundaries of the data, and this is biting the total implementation in such operations.

It’s an interesting read, and a little disappointing.

Joe Obbish digs into bitmap filters and clustered columnstore indexes:

The position of the bitmap has changed so that it’s evaluated after the key lookup. That makes sense because the key lookup returns the column to be filtered against. However, the bitmap filter still reduces the estimated number of key lookups from 3000000 to 3000. This is impossible. The filter can only be applied after the key lookup, so it does not make sense for the bitmap to reduce the number of estimated executions of the key lookup.

Performance is significantly worse with the query now requiring 12199107 logical reads from the rowstore table and 13406 CPU time overall. We can see that the query did three million key lookups:

This is a fairly deep post, so you’ll probably want to check out the Paul White post on bitmaps first.

Joe Obbish explains a quirk of columnstore index compression:

The insert query now takes 3594 ms of CPU time and 2112 ms of elapsed time on my machine. The size of each rowgroup did not change. It’s still 2098320 bytes. Even though this is a parallel query there’s no element of randomness in this case. In the query plan we can see that the source table was scanned in a serial zone and round robin distribution is to used to distribute exactly half of the rows to each parallel thread.

This seems like a reasonable plan given that TOP forces a serial zone and we need to preserve order. It’s possible to rewrite the query to encourage a parallel scan of the source table, but that would introduce an order-preserving gather streams operator.

Click through for the full story.