Kieran Healy scratches his head:
I just finished driving a very long way up the side of the country, so I’m kind of tired. But even allowing for that, boy, this way of representing things really is quite confusing. Not being an Apple Sports user I had to look at it for a bit to understand what was happening. But, now that it has given me a headache, I can kind of see why whoever designed this ended up in the undoubtedly bad place they did.
Before I get to why I have some sympathy for the designer, why did I find this representation of these numbers so disorienting? It’s not just just because I’ve been driving for nine hours. John is right to call the picture a “Zero Sum” representation. The design strongly suggests to the viewer that, within each row, we’re looking at each team’s share of a total. Each pair of black and blue lines seem to be vying for control of their whole row, with the longest line being the “winner” in each case.
Click through for the challenge, as well as a trio of attempts to improve the results. The tornado chart at the end is probably what I’d go with if I needed to include all of this on a single chart. H/T R-Bloggers.