The Halloween Problem And Deleting From Self-Referencing Tables

Louis Davdison walks us through a case where deleting from a table can be extremely slow:

I have a great interest in hierarchy solutions, as I plan to write a book on implementing hierarchies in SQL Server in the next year or so (after I see what happens in SQL Server vNext after 2017). Something I didn’t include in my design testing when I built my presentation on hierarchies (available from a link here) a few years back was the cost to remove nodes from a tree. I learned a big lesson today about the cost of deleting from a hierarchy (the hard way). It is definitely something I will be digging deeper into at some point in a lab environment, comparing multiple methods of deleting from a hierarchy, but I wanted to write down the issue with self-referencing table for future use (and hopefully for your use too.)

We have a table with 100s of millions of rows, and deletes from this table were taking forever. There were 17 foreign key constraints to this table, but each of the references were only showing as 1% of the plan. The physical DELETE from the clustered index operator was ~80%, but in the query, there showed up an operator that looked ominous.

Definitely worth a read.

Related Posts

Offloading Code Review Burdens with Automation

Ed Elliott argues that automation and testing can make code reviews easier: OK so if we break this down into what a DBA should be doing as part of a code review: – Ensure formatting is correct and any standards followed– Have they introduces a SQL injection vulnerability?– Consider any side effects of the actual […]

Read More

Tracking xp_cmdshell Executions

Jason Brimhall shows how you can see when someone calls xp_cmdshell, including the call details: What was the wait_type? Well, the obscure wait_type was called PREEMPTIVE_OS_PIPEOPS. What causes this wait? As it turns out, this is a generic wait that is caused by SQL pipe related activities such as xp_cmdshell. Knowing this much information however does not […]

Read More

Categories

July 2018
MTWTFSS
« Jun Aug »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031