The Dangers Of The Ellipsis In R

Kevin Feasel



John Mount shows us an example where ... (the ellipsis) can come back to hurt us:

The following code example contains an easy error in using the Rfunction unique().

vec1 <- c("a", "b", "c")
vec2 <- c("c", "d")
unique(vec1, vec2)
# [1] "a" "b" "c"

Notice none of the novel values from vec2 are present in the result. Our mistake was: we (improperly) tried to use unique() with multiple value arguments, as one would use union(). Also notice no error or warning was signaled. We used unique() incorrectly and nothing pointed this out to us. What compounded our error was R‘s “...” function signature feature.

John makes it clear that ... is not itself a bad thing, just that there is a time and a place for it and misusing it can lead to hard-to-understand bugs.

Related Posts

Defining Tidy Data

John Mount shares thoughts about the concept of tidy data: A question is: is such a data set “tidy”? The paper itself claims the above definitions are “Codd’s 3rd normal form.” So, no the above table is not “tidy” under that paper’s definition. The the winner’s date of birth is a fact about the winner […]

Read More

Visualizing Earthquake Data

Giorgio Garziano continues a series on analyzing earthquake data: This is the third part of our post series about the exploratory analysis of a publicly available dataset reporting earthquakes and similar events within a specific 30 days time span. In this post, we are going to show static, interactive and animated earthquakes maps of different flavors by […]

Read More


June 2018
« May Jul »