ROWGROUP_FLUSH Deadlocks Inserting Into Clustered Columnstore Indexes

Joe Obbish ran into a strange deadlock when performing concurrent insertions into a clustered columnstore index:

We’ve only observed this deadlock with multiple concurrent sessions insert to the delta store for the same target CCI due to server memory pressure or very low cardinality estimates (less than 251 rows). The correct mitigation depends on why you’re seeing the issue in the first place. If you’re seeing it due to low cardinality estimates then fix your estimates, or at the very least get them above 250 rows. If you’re seeing them because the memory grant for the CCI build times out after 25 seconds then lower concurrency or increase server memory.

The problem can also be avoided by not doing concurrent inserts in the first place. In some cases a parallel insert may be a reasonable alterative. There’s also some evidence that the deadlock is only seen when the number of rows for insert is very close to 1048576, but we weren’t able to make any definitive conclusions around that.

Read the whole thing.  Also check out his Connect item.

Related Posts

Sliding Window Partitioning And Columnstore Indexes

Dmitri Korotkevitch walks through setting up sliding window partitioning on tables with columnstore indexes: The biggest difference resides in partition function split and merge behavior. With B-Tree indexes, you can split and merge non-empty partitions. SQL Server would split or merge the data automatically, granted with the schema-modification (Sch-M) table lock held in place. Other sessions would […]

Read More

A Columnstore Trick With No Practical Value

Joe Obbish explains a quirk of columnstore index compression: The insert query now takes 3594 ms of CPU time and 2112 ms of elapsed time on my machine. The size of each rowgroup did not change. It’s still 2098320 bytes. Even though this is a parallel query there’s no element of randomness in this case. […]

Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories

November 2017
MTWTFSS
« Oct  
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930