The Pain Of Multi-Statement TVFs

Andy Mallon walks through a multi-statement table-valued function in Microsoft Dynamics CRM:

Look at all those table-valued function calls! Followed immediately by a really expensive hash match. My Spidey Sense started to tingle. What is fn_GetMaxPrivilegeDepthMask, and why is it being called 30 times? I bet this is a problem. When you see “Table-valued function” as an operator in a plan, that actually means it’s a multi-statement table-valued function. If it were an inline table-valued function, it would get incorporated into the larger plan, and not be a black box. Multi-statement table-valued functions are evil. Don’t use them. The Cardinality Estimator isn’t able to make accurate estimates. The Query Optimizer isn’t able to optimize them in the context of the larger query. From a performance perspective, they don’t scale.

Even though this TVF is an out-of-the-box piece of code from Dynamics CRM, my Spidey Sense tells me that it’s the problem.

That said, Joe Sack and team are working on making multi-statement TVFs faster in SQL Server 2017.  Whether it will move the needle from Andy’s excellent advice, we’ll have to wait and see.

Related Posts

Bitwise Logic To Make Values Negative

David Fowler is working with arcane magic: The short answer to the question is to simply apply a bitwise NOT to the number that you want to convert and add 1 to the result.  I wrote about bitwise logic in The Arcane Science of Bitwise Logic and SQL Server but didn’t mention the bitwise NOT. If you […]

Read More

Executing Dynamic SQL: EXEC vs sp_executesql

Tara Kizer gives a scenario where using sp_executesql can result in lower CPU utilization than EXEC: For frequently executed queries, “EXEC sp_executesql @sql”is a good choice but at the risk of encountering parameter sniffing issues. For queries that aren’t executed very often, “EXEC (@sql)” can be used, but you could end up with a bloated […]

Read More

Categories

August 2017
MTWTFSS
« Jul Sep »
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031