Checkpointing Code For Reproduction

Kevin Feasel

2017-08-16

R

David Smith tells an interesting story about a reproducibility problem with data analysis:

Timo Grossenbacher, data journalist with Swiss Radio and TV in Zurich, had a bit of a surprise when he attempted to recreate the results of one of the R Markdown scripts published by SRF Data to accompany their data journalism story about vested interests of Swiss members of parliament. Upon re-running the analysis in R last week, Timo was surprised when the results differed from those published in August 2015. There was no change to the R scripts or data in the intervening two-year period, so what caused the results to be different?

The version of R Timo was using had been updated, but that wasn’t the root cause of the problem. What had also changed was the version of the dplyr package used by the script: version 0.5.0 now, versus version 0.4.2 then. For some unknown reason, a change in the dplyr package in the intervening package caused some data rows (shown in red above) to be deleted during the data preparation process, and so the results changed.

Click through for the solution, which is pretty easy in R.

Related Posts

Probabilities And Poker

Steve Miller has a notebook on 5-card draw probabilities: The population of 5 card draw hands, consisting of 52 choose 5 or 2598960 elements, is pretty straightforward both mathematically and statistically. So of course ever the geek, I just had to attempt to show her how probability and statistics converge. In addition to explaining the […]

Read More

Principal Component Analysis With Stack Overflow Data

Julia Silge explains Principal Component Analysis and shows us an example using Stack Overflow data: We have tidy data, both because that’s what I get when querying our databases and because it is useful for exploratory data analysis when preparing for a machine learning algorithm like PCA. To implement PCA, we need a matrix, and […]

Read More

Categories

August 2017
MTWTFSS
« Jul Sep »
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031