Once upon a time, I was really excited about getting this configuration item in SQL Server 2008. Early versions of SQL Server 2005 weren’t all that great at managing the size of the execution plan cache: it could really balloon up and eat away at the buffer pool. But the SQL Server team did a good job at tuning those algorithms in later service packs for 2005 and future versions, and it became much less of an issue.
Personally, I’ve never had a case where enabling ‘Optimize for Adhoc Workloads’ improved performance in a way that I could measure. It may save you a small amount of memory, it may not.
I don’t mean this as a big insult. Trying to save a penny every time you go to the grocery store could add up, if you grocery shop very frequently. But hopefully that’s not one of your major revenue sources over time.
It’s an interesting counter-argument and worth reading.