More With Adaptive Joins

Erik Darling continues his adaptive joins exploration with two more posts.  First, how local variables can affect the query plan:

The easiest way to look at this is to compare Adaptive Joins with literal values to the same ones using local variables. The results are a little… complicated.

Here are three queries with three literal values. In my copy of the Super User database (the largest Stack Overflow sub-site), I’ve made copies of all the tables and added Clustered ColumnStore indexes to them. That’s the only way to get Adaptive Joins at this point — Column Store has to be involved somewhere along the line.

The last day of data in this dump is from December 11. When I query the data, I’m looking at the last 11 days of data, the last day of data, and then a day where there isn’t any data.

Then Erik takes on non-SARGable queries:

The queries with non-SARGable predicates on the Users table used Adaptive Joins.

The queries with non-SARGable predicates on the Posts table did not.

Now, there is an Extended Events… er… event to track this, called adaptive_join_skipped, however it didn’t seem to log any information for the queries that didn’t get Adaptive Joins.

Bummer! But, if I had to wager a guess, it would be that this happens because there’s no alternative Index Seek plan for the Posts table with those predicates. Their non-SARGableness takes that choice away from the optimizer, and so Adaptive Joins aren’t a choice. The Users table is going to get scanned either way — that’s the nature of ColumnStore indexes, so it can withstand the misery of non-SARGable predicates in this case and use the Adaptive Join.

Two more good posts in Erik’s series, and both definitely worth reading.

Related Posts

Using Plan Guides

Kendra Little has a video showing how to use plan guides: If you need to add, remove, or replace hints from ad-hoc queries where you can’t change the code, plan guides can help. See a demo of removing a query hint from parameterized TSQL run from an application, and get tips on how to make […]

Read More

More On Adaptive Joins

Erik Darling has a couple more posts on adaptive joins in SQL Server 2017.  First, he wonders what happens when you add scalar functions to the mix: See, this isn’t SARGable either (and no, SCHEMABINDING doesn’t change this). When a predicate isn’t SARGable, you take away an index seek as an access choice. You don’t […]

Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Categories

May 2017
MTWTFSS
« Apr  
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031